Mystic Hill Olde Barn Gift Shop

Share this

Specializing in the sale of local Amish wares and unique country gifts,  including a large selection of moose, bear, chicken, cow and pig items for sale.  Visit their Christ"Moose" section!

Amish cookbooks, rugs, leather bells, birdhouses, unfinished pine furniture.  Non Amish or "English" ~ Candles, soaps, rugs, blankets, metal signs, carvings, and much more...

Mystic Hill Olde Barn is a family owned business supplying the local Amish Community and other local vendors a place to market their goods. They understand that the roadside sales of the Amish is part of their livelihood, and in keeping with this spirit they purchase merchandise from them at a very slight discount and resell it at about the same price you would pay if you were buying directly from them.  In the fall, they grow and sell sweet corn & pumpkins.


Mystic Hill Olde Barn logo

Hours of Operation:

April, May & Nov., Dec.

Thursday – Saturday 10 am – 5 pm. Closed Sun thru Wed.

June – October

Tuesday thru Saturday 10 am – 5 pm. Closed Sun & Mon

When They are Closed

On days and hours they are not open,
we ask that you please call as they live nearby.
(716) 912-0981

Boys having fun at Mystic Hill Olde Barn
Mystic Hill Olde Barn
7840 Mosher Hollow Road
Cattaraugus, NY 14719
United States
Phone: 716-912-0981
42° 20' 23.19" N, 78° 57' 25.4772" W

General Information

  • Wheelchair Accessible: No
  • Parking: Yes
  • RV Parking: No
  • Bus Parking: No
  • Pets Allowed: No
  • Accepts Credit Cards: Yes
  • Internet Access: No
  • Conference / Meeting / Banquet: No
  • Playground: Unknown
  • Indoor Pool: Unknown
  • Outdoor Pool: Unknown
  • Swimming:
  • Boat Launch or Dock: No
  • Fishing Access: None
  • Equestrian Trail Access: Unknown
  • Bicycle Trail Access: Unknown
  • Hiking Trail Access: Unknown
  • Mountain Biking Trail Access: Unknown
  • Snowmobile Trail Access: Unknown

Please note

Please note that this information may change and may be incorrect

Mystic Hill Olde Barn Gift Shop is categorized in

#1 for Turkey Hunting and in the Top 3 for Deer Hunting

Cattaraugus County was named #1 overall by New York Game and Fish Magazine for turkey hunting and is in the top three for deer hunting by DEC reports.

Read more